Meta Warns It May Withdraw Encrypted Services from Canada Over Bill C-22
Company says proposed lawful access legislation could undermine the security of encrypted communications
Meta has warned that it may consider withdrawing some of its services from Canada if the federal government's proposed lawful access legislation, Bill C-22, is passed without further amendments.
The company's representatives raised concerns during a Senate national security committee hearing on Monday, arguing that the proposed legislation could weaken the protection provided by end-to-end encryption and expose private communications to security risks.
Bill C-22 seeks to require technology companies to develop systems capable of providing information to law enforcement agencies when presented with a warrant.
Meta Director of Privacy and Public Policy Robyn Greene told senators that complying with the proposed requirements while maintaining secure end-to-end encrypted services would not be technically feasible.
Meta's platforms include Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp, whose messaging service offers end-to-end encryption.
When asked whether the company could withdraw some of its services from Canada if the legislation takes effect, Meta's Head of Public Policy for Canada, Rachel Curran, said the company would examine all available options and would have to consider that possibility.
How Bill C-22 Would Affect Technology Companies
Beyond requiring companies to provide information to investigators with a warrant, Bill C-22 would give the public safety minister authority to direct electronic service providers operating in Canada to establish surveillance and monitoring capabilities within their systems.
The minister would also be able to issue confidential orders requiring companies to develop such capabilities. These orders would first be reviewed by the intelligence commissioner, an independent quasi-judicial official.
Before the bill was referred to the Senate in June, Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree introduced amendments intended to limit the circumstances in which companies could be required to decrypt information.
Another amendment reduced the proposed metadata retention period from as long as 12 months to six months. The change followed warnings from cybersecurity experts that retaining large volumes of information could make it a valuable target for hackers.
However, Meta's Curran argued that the revisions did not provide sufficient protection, saying they addressed only the central components of encryption while leaving other essential layers exposed.
Signal and Apple Also Raise Concerns
Meta is not the only technology company opposing aspects of the proposed legislation. Encrypted messaging platform Signal has repeatedly warned that it could leave the Canadian market if the bill is passed in its current form.
Signal Vice-President Udbhav Tiwari told the Senate committee that the company would not compromise the security of its users, even if that meant withdrawing its services from Canada.
He urged lawmakers to make further changes to the legislation and include clear guarantees protecting encrypted communications.
Apple has also criticised the proposed amendments, warning that the bill could still undermine its ability to provide users with strong privacy and security features, including encryption.
The company said the potential risks were particularly concerning as artificial intelligence and other emerging technologies provide cybercriminals with additional tools to exploit security weaknesses.
Privacy Commissioner Seeks Further Safeguards
The Canadian government has defended Bill C-22, saying law enforcement agencies need updated legal tools to prevent crime, investigate offences and respond to emerging security threats.
Despite that position, the legislation has faced sustained criticism from technology companies, cybersecurity specialists and privacy advocates. It is the second lawful access bill introduced by the government during the current parliamentary session.
Earlier this month, Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne urged senators to strengthen the proposed protections for Canadians' personal information.
One major concern involves a proposed reduction in the legal threshold required for law enforcement and intelligence agencies to obtain basic subscriber information from electronic service providers.
Under the bill, authorities would need only reasonable grounds to suspect that an offence has been or will be committed, rather than the higher standard of reasonable grounds to believe.
The information covered includes names, residential addresses, telephone numbers, email addresses and account numbers.
Dufresne argued that the definition of subscriber information and the range of organisations that could be compelled to disclose it remain too broad, particularly given the lower threshold proposed for accessing such records.
As the Senate continues its examination of Bill C-22, the debate centres on how Canada can equip law enforcement with investigative tools without weakening encryption, compromising digital security or exposing private information to misuse.
Source: CBC News
