Fountain of Life Church Crisis Deepens as Court Restrains Jimmy Odukoya, Pastor Explains Succession Video
Court order, disputed succession recording and disagreements over board leadership add new dimensions to the church's leadership crisis
The leadership crisis at The Fountain of Life Church in Lagos has taken another turn following a court order restraining its embattled Senior Pastor, Jimmy Odukoya, from presenting himself as the head of the church.
The development comes amid an escalating dispute between Odukoya and members of the church's Board of Trustees over his leadership, the succession arrangement made by his late father, Pastor Taiwo Odukoya, and the administration of the church.
In separate developments reported on Wednesday and Thursday, Odukoya gave his account of the disagreement while addressing church workers, explaining why he kept a video in which his father named a preferred successor and recounting a dream he said strengthened his determination to resist pressure from the board.
Court Restrains Jimmy Odukoya
A Lagos State High Court has restrained Odukoya from parading himself as the Senior Pastor of The Fountain of Life Church.
According to a report by TheCable, Justice O.O. Adewunmi-Oshin issued the order following a suit filed by the Incorporated Trustees of the church.
The court also prohibited Odukoya from taking any action or making any representation suggesting that he remains in charge of the church as its senior pastor.
The church, founded by the late Pastor Taiwo Odukoya, has yet to issue an official statement on the court order.
Odukoya Explains Why He Kept Succession Video
Speaking to about 300 church workers on Wednesday, Jimmy explained the circumstances surrounding a video recorded in 2021, in which his father reportedly identified Pastor Kunle Areogun as his preferred successor.
He said the recording was made while his father was preparing for surgery in the United States and was concerned that he might not survive the procedure. According to Jimmy, his father asked him to record the succession message, and his elder brother, Pastor John Odukoya, was also aware of it.
"That was when he asked me to record him where he made the statements about succession. I was the one who recorded the video."
Jimmy said that after his father successfully recovered from surgery, he was instructed to delete the recording because the circumstances that prompted it had changed. However, he admitted that he retained the video instead of deleting it, describing that decision as a serious mistake.
He also claimed that only a small number of people knew about the recording, including his sisters, whom he alleged were responsible for making it public.
The video later became central to the succession controversy after some trustees questioned the process that led to Jimmy's appointment as senior pastor in September 2023, following his father's death in August of that year.
Disagreement Over Board Chairmanship
Odukoya traced the disagreement with the Board of Trustees to about a year after he assumed leadership of the church.
He said some board members asked him to relinquish his position as Chairman of the Board of Trustees while continuing as senior pastor. He rejected the proposal, claiming he believed it was an attempt to control him and weaken his authority.
He further alleged that his elder sister, Pastor Tolu Odukoya-Ijogun, approached him and asked him to step aside as board chairman so she could take over the position.
The disagreement reportedly continued despite interventions by Bishop Mike Okonkwo, who appealed to Jimmy to relinquish the chairmanship.
Jimmy said the matter was eventually taken to the General Overseer of the Redeemed Christian Church of God, Pastor Enoch Adeboye, for intervention.
Recounting the meeting, he alleged that members of the board made false claims against him in Adeboye's presence. According to the account, Adeboye allowed him to present his side before advising the parties to resolve their differences. He also reportedly reminded Jimmy that his primary calling was to preach the gospel rather than occupy the position of board chairman.
Jimmy Says Late Father Appeared in His Dream
In another account of the crisis, Odukoya disclosed that he turned to fasting and prayer while seeking direction on how to handle the disagreement with the trustees.
He said he asked God for guidance through either a dream or an encounter with someone he did not know who could provide clarity.
According to him, his late father appeared in a dream during the period of fasting and prayer, with a message encouraging him not to give in to pressure from the board.
"The message I got from the dream was that I should not succumb to the threats of the Board of Trustees. He told me that they would try to throw dirt on me, but that I would overcome."
He also said that shortly after the dream, he met another pastor who advised him that the board would continue to create difficulties for him if he did not remove its members.
Jimmy said the two experiences strengthened his resolve to maintain his position and subsequently ask members of the board, including his elder sister, to resign.
He claimed he proposed that his sister could be reconsidered for membership after the church had been given a fresh start, but said his sisters rejected the suggestion while the board maintained its position.
Trustees Withdraw Recognition, Church Rejects Decision
The dispute escalated after some members of the Board of Trustees announced on November 16 that they no longer recognised Jimmy as the church's senior pastor. They also named Pastor Rotimi Okpaise as interim spiritual and administrative leader.
The trustees reportedly based their decision partly on the 2021 succession video, which they said was not presented during the process that led to Jimmy's appointment in September 2023.
According to the trustees, the late founder had indicated that Pastor Kunle Areogun should succeed him, with Jimmy serving as Areogun's administrative assistant and leading the youth church.
They also raised concerns about Jimmy's remarriage and the public blessing of his marriage, arguing that these matters conflicted with the church's teachings and standards for spiritual leadership.
However, the church rejected the trustees' announcement, describing the purported removal as unconstitutional. It maintained that Jimmy remained its duly appointed senior pastor and chairman of the Board of Trustees, following a unanimous appointment in September 2023.
The church also alleged that the trustees behind the removal announcement had been asked to resign in March 2026 over alleged breaches of its constitution.
With the trustees' decision, the church's rejection of that move, Jimmy's account of the succession recording and the latest court order, the leadership dispute remains a major issue surrounding the administration of The Fountain of Life Church.
Sources: PUNCH, Daily Post Nigeria and TheCable
