Log In
LATEST VYPA Blog

Alberta’s Dual-Practice Health Model Raises Fears of Two-Tiered Healthcare System

Alberta’s Dual-Practice Health Model Raises Fears of Two-Tiered Healthcare System

Alberta's decision to allow doctors to work in both public hospitals and private clinics has sparked concerns that the move could worsen waiting times and deepen inequality in Canada's healthcare system.

The controversial dual-practice model, introduced under Bill 11, allows eligible physicians to provide services in both sectors. While the provincial government says the policy will increase surgical capacity and reduce delays, health advocates warn it could divert medical professionals from public hospitals and make access to faster treatment dependent on patients' ability to pay.

The debate has drawn attention to patients who have spent years waiting for essential procedures, including hip and knee replacements.

Patients Face Long Waits and Rising Pain

One of those affected is Cheryl Stewart, who waited nearly three years on Alberta's public waiting list for a hip replacement. She is finally scheduled to undergo surgery this week.

Stewart told CBC's The National that her condition deteriorated over time, leaving her barely able to walk beyond the short distance between her bedroom, kitchen and bathroom.

She said paying privately for the procedure, which could cost about $35,000, was not an option.

"It's a two-tiered system. You certainly don't feel like you're in the upper tier, that's for sure," she said, describing the arrangement as unfair to people who have paid taxes but cannot afford private treatment.

Another patient, Neil Payne, from Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island, faced an estimated 12 to 18-month wait for hip surgery. After six months away from work and experiencing severe pain, he travelled to a Montreal clinic for treatment, accumulating more than $20,000 in debt.

Despite the financial burden, Payne described the surgery as life-changing.

Concerns Over Public Healthcare Waiting Times

Data from the Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI) shows significant differences in access to hip replacement surgery across the country's largest provinces.

Canada's national benchmark recommends that patients receive hip and knee replacements within six months of the procedure being ordered.

However, 84 per cent of patients in Ontario receive hip replacements within that timeframe, compared with 54 per cent of public patients in Quebec. Alberta currently records 63 per cent, below the national average of 69 per cent.

Quebec has more than 800 doctors who have opted out of the public healthcare system to work privately. Although physicians in the province cannot practise in both systems simultaneously, regulations introduced last year require government approval before they can switch from public to private practice.

International experiences have also raised doubts about whether expanding private healthcare improves public waiting times. A 2024 study of Australia's healthcare system found that efforts to expand private care had only a limited impact, reducing public hospital waiting times by less than half a day on average.

A May article in The Lancet also warned that expanding private practice in Australia, Ireland and the United Kingdom had worsened inequalities and increased surgical waiting times.

Alberta Defends Dual-Practice Policy

Alberta's government maintains that the new model will increase the number of procedures performed without weakening public healthcare services.

Premier Danielle Smith said about 400 doctors had expressed interest in the arrangement. She added that the government would ensure participating physicians continue providing the public services they have historically delivered.

Under the proposed safeguards, doctors may be required to meet minimum operating-room hours in the public system. Family physicians are excluded from the arrangement, while cancer care, emergency services and other life-saving treatments are not covered.

Maddison McKee, press secretary to Alberta's minister of hospital and surgical health services, said dual practice would apply to a limited range of elective procedures and provide patients with an additional option.

The government has also committed to delivering 50,000 additional publicly funded surgeries over the next three years.

Experts Warn of Conflict of Interest

Health policy experts have questioned whether the proposed safeguards will be sufficient to prevent doctors from prioritising more lucrative private procedures over publicly funded operations.

Karen Palmer, a health policy professor at Simon Fraser University, argued that dual-practice arrangements have harmful effects that regulation has failed to eliminate elsewhere.

She warned that the system could create incentives for physicians to allow public waiting times to increase, leaving patients feeling pressured to pay for faster treatment.

Alberta physician Dr. Braden Manns, senior associate dean of the Cumming School of Medicine at the University of Calgary, also warned that doctors could prioritise private procedures because of the higher financial returns.

Manns co-authored a commentary in the Canadian Medical Association Journal arguing that dual practice could worsen access to public healthcare.

However, Dr. John Antoniou, an orthopaedic surgeon who works in both public and private healthcare in Quebec, maintained that private clinics could complement public services if appropriate safeguards were in place.

Nova Scotia Offers an Alternative Approach

Critics of Alberta's policy point to Nova Scotia as an example of how public healthcare waiting times can be reduced through changes within the existing system.

The province has improved access to elective surgeries by introducing a centralised referral waiting list, extending operating-room hours to nights and weekends, and improving hospital efficiency.

As a result, 77 per cent of hip replacement patients in Nova Scotia now receive surgery within the national benchmark, compared with 49 per cent in 2022.

Health advocates argue that improving public hospital capacity and efficiency offers a more equitable solution than expanding private healthcare options.

Health Groups Call for Federal Intervention

More than 20 Canadian health organisations have called on Prime Minister Mark Carney and federal Health Minister Marjorie Michel to review Alberta's Bill 11 and intervene if the legislation is found to violate the Canada Health Act.

Michel has previously expressed concerns about the province's dual-practice model, but it remains unclear whether the federal government will take action, including withholding public healthcare funding.

For patients waiting in pain, the debate raises a fundamental question about the future of Canada's healthcare system: whether access to timely treatment should depend on medical need or the ability to pay.

CBC News

Ready to get started with VYPA?

Join thousands of businesses already broadcasting smarter.

Start Free Today